Longboat Key's 2026 season is starting with a rebuilt middle. Along the 3100 block of Gulf of Mexico Drive, a coffee shop now fills a space Hurricane Helene emptied, a bookstore sits where there wasn't one a year ago, and a planned national chain decided not to come. Most of the dated events on the island's fall calendar are at Town Center Green, Town Hall and Bayfront Park. Both the businesses and the events count on the same people turning up: the full-time residents the Longboat Key Chamber of Commerce spent the summer asking to stay on the island and spend locally.
The 3100 block, rebuilt one storefront at a time
The clearest example sits at 3172 Gulf of Mexico Drive. Turtle Coffee Bar used to operate there, and it never reopened after Helene pushed waist-high water into the store in 2024. Next door, at 3174, a Starbucks had been announced in February 2025. In January 2026 its would-be operator, Greg Sausaman, told the Longboat Observer, "We are no longer moving forward with a Starbucks at this location," and added, "We wish the new coffee shop well." No replacement tenant for 3174 has been reported since then.
The new coffee shop he meant is Sips. Sips started at Whitney Plaza, 6828 Gulf of Mexico Drive, and had been open almost three years when it took over the old Turtle Coffee space. The second location opened in March 2026 with no formal announcement. Co-owner Chris Carter called it a soft opening that ran on word of mouth and passing traffic. "Our goal was to get open kind of at the beginning of the season," he said. "Now we're in the back end of the season."
That makes this fall the first full season for the mid-key Sips. The shop is small. It covers 859 square feet with one indoor table, and most of the room goes to the kitchen and espresso bar. There's a small outdoor seating area, and a public beach access sits across the street. The menu differs a little from the north-end shop. It adds a build-your-own breakfast sandwich, plus acai bowls, baked goods, smoothies and juices. Carter said the second store would probably rotate specialty latte flavors more often than the original.
A few doors down, Brista Commons filled in over the winter. Its tenants held official openings on Jan. 20. Couch LBK opened at 3130 Gulf of Mexico Drive, selling furniture and home furnishings with free design consultations and consignment. Your Flooring Warehouse opened an island showroom at 3140, and ClearView Windows & Doors opened at 3150 with a line that includes hurricane-resistant windows and doors. A post-storm island now has a hurricane-window showroom, a flooring store and a consignment furniture shop in the same plaza.
Next door, the Brista Commons outparcel building holds the Goodwill Manasota bookstore and donation center. It opened Dec. 18, 2025, after about a year of planning. Keera Herbst, regional director of donated goods retail, said it stocked about 13,000 books at opening, from rare collectibles to children's books and comics, along with records and other media. The store added seven jobs on the island. Donating is quick. Goodwill Manasota President and CEO Donn Githens said there are two parking spots in back by the automatic door, and staff are trained to come out within 10 seconds to take donations and hand over a gift receipt.
What "rebuilding" meant to the people running these shops
These openings matter more because of what business owners said this summer. In June, the Chamber and the town held their first "Let's Talk Business" roundtable. About a dozen people came, and the conversation centered on how hard the slow months are. Chamber President Kim Verrault put it this way:
"It's probably important for us to remind our locals that these businesses are here, and they're really here for them, and to get out and explore what's available to them. There are some incredible merchants here, there are some incredible restaurateurs that are here, and there are things at their fingertips right now."
She described Longboat Key as still in a rebuilding phase after the 2024 hurricanes, not a growth phase. She also said the island's roughly 7,500 full-time residents can support its small businesses all year if more of them leave the house and spend locally. Assistant Town Manager Isaac Brownman described the town's goal as keeping "a certain style and character of the island while balancing that with the need for businesses to survive and thrive."
The middle of the island fits that description. None of these openings is a big new development. They are a café in a flooded-out suite, a donation-fed bookstore, and a plaza of home-related shops serving people who are still repairing. Sips gives the stretch a daily reason to stop in. Carter has said foot traffic usually keeps the shop busy through summer.
Town Hall is changing too. The second Let's Talk Business roundtable was set for Sept. 16 at Town Hall, 501 Bay Isles Road, and 17 guests registered. No account of what came out of it has been published yet. George Landry also took over from Howard Tipton as town manager in mid-September, so the season starts under new leadership at Town Hall.
The fall calendar, in order
Most of the island's dated fall events take place at town-run spaces: Town Center Green and Town Hall on Bay Isles Road, and Bayfront Park at 4052 Gulf of Mexico Drive.
- Oct. 10, noon to 4 p.m. "Think Pink: Sip, Shop & Support" at J.McLaughlin on Longboat Key, listed on the Chamber calendar.
- Oct. 13, 3 p.m. The town's "Let's Talk Longboat" meeting at Bayfront Park, 4052 Gulf of Mexico Drive. Two more are scheduled for Nov. 18 and Dec. 16, also at 3 p.m.
- Oct. 24, 8 a.m. to noon A community cleanup starting at Town Hall, 501 Bay Isles Road.
- Nov. 11, 4 to 6 p.m. The town's Veterans Day celebration at Town Center Green, 600 Bay Isles Road. It's free, with live music, refreshments and food trucks before and after the ceremony. Last year's event also marked the town's 70th anniversary and the U.S. Army's 250th.
- Saturday, Nov. 21, 5 to 8 p.m. Light Up Longboat at Town Center Green, with food vendors, music and the tree lighting. An earlier Observer listing gave the end time as 7 p.m. The Chamber's current event page says 8.
Taken together, these events give people a reason to be in the center of the island about once a week from mid-October to Thanksgiving, then again in mid-December. On the cleanup morning or a Let's Talk Longboat afternoon, you can easily add a coffee at 3172 or a stop at the Goodwill bookstore next to Brista Commons.
Elsewhere on the island this season
New openings aren't limited to the middle. AGCF, the brand founded by Alexandra Gucci Zarini, plans to open its second boutique "later this fall" in the lobby of The St. Regis Longboat Key Resort. It will carry handbags, small leather goods, scarves, jewelry and eyewear. No opening date has been announced. The Buccaneer is still in design at the former Pattigeorge's site. Dock work was underway in August, and the Observer reported "no timetable" for when it will be finished.
A few practical notes for the first weeks of season
- Coffee near the beach. The mid-key Sips at 3172 Gulf of Mexico Drive has one indoor table and a small outdoor seating area, across the street from a public beach access.
- Dropping off donations. The Goodwill bookstore and donation center next to Brista Commons has two dedicated spots in back by the automatic door.
- Post-storm projects. Brista Commons now has an island showroom for flooring at Your Flooring Warehouse and for windows and doors, including hurricane-resistant products, at ClearView.
- Two dates for the calendar. Veterans Day at Town Center Green on Nov. 11 and Light Up Longboat on Nov. 21.
At Alexis Smith-Frady, we keep track of Longboat Key block by block, including which storefronts have come back since the storms and which corners of the island are busy this season. Whether you're settling in for the winter or thinking about your next move on the Key, we'd be glad to share what we know. Work with Us.